Executive Summary
Despite technological and economic changes, financial services remain the backbone of economic infrastructure. The competitive landscape, however, has shifted in ways that scale alone can no longer offset, and the gap between the institutions that recognize this and the ones still relying on legacy advantages is widening.
Between 2019 and 2024, funds intermediated by the global banking system grew by $122 trillion, about 40 percent, propelled by household and institutional wealth. Bank revenues after risk cost reached a record $5.5 trillion in 2024.1 In 2025, net income rose again, to a record $1.3 trillion, the most of any industry.2 By most financial measures, the sector is performing well.
Still, the market remains unconvinced. The banking sector’s price-to-book ratio is 1, 67 percent below the average for other industries.1 Labour productivity growth has been mixed, even though banks spend a higher share of revenue on technology than any other sector.3 While profitability is real, confidence is not.
The reason is a gap in execution more than a lack of ambition. Financial services institutions are being asked to modernize customer journeys, technology platforms, and decision-making systems while simultaneously meeting higher expectations on risk, compliance, and operational reliability. Doing all of that at once, without destabilizing what already works, is an execution challenge of genuine complexity, and that is the problem we are built to help solve.
Current Challenges: Regulation, Cyber Risk, and New Competition Are Converging
Three forces are converging at the same time, putting pressure on financial services leaders, and each one demands a response that is both operationally disciplined and strategically coherent.
Regulatory Expectations Continue to Expand in Scope and Specificity
Regulatory requirements have moved well beyond capital and liquidity into operational resilience, third-party technology oversight, and consumer data access. The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision revised its Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision in April 2024, the first revision since 2012, introducing a revised Principle 25 that brings operational risk and operational resilience together under a single supervisory expectation.4 The Committee’s 2021 Principles for Operational Resilience spell out what that means in practice: governance, operational risk management, business continuity, third-party dependencies, incident management, and resilient information and communication technology, including cybersecurity.5
Under those principles, supervisors expect banks to operate with an adequate operational resilience approach that reflects their risk profile, risk appetite, business environment, and tolerance for disruption to critical operations. That includes policies and processes to identify and protect against threats, respond to disruptive events, and minimize the impact on the delivery of critical operations.5
In Europe, the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) has applied since January 17, 2025, and requires banks and other financial firms to report major technology incidents and to test their digital resilience regularly.6 While DORA applies directly to EU-regulated institutions, its influence is being felt across global financial services as a signal of where supervisory expectations are heading more broadly.
The implication for leaders is that compliance is no longer separable from transformation. Resilience cannot be delivered as a parallel control layer. It has to be embedded into how change initiatives are designed and executed from the outset.
Nonbank Competition Is Gaining Structural Ground
The more profitable pools in banking are facing competition from focused nonbank attackers in private credit, payments, and wealth management.3 These competitors are not constrained by legacy infrastructure or the full weight of prudential regulation. They move faster, design more targeted propositions, and are capturing share in precisely the areas where incumbent margins are strongest.
Institutions that are large but operationally complex are not automatically better positioned than focused competitors with cleaner operating models. The advantage that used to come from balance sheet size is now contingent on something more uncomfortable: the ability to execute.
Cyber Exposure Is Material and Growing
As institutions adopt more cloud, API, and AI-enabled architectures, the attack surface expands. The Basel Committee treats cybersecurity as a core part of operational resilience in its 2021 Principles for Operational Resilience, which it published alongside its revised Principles for the Sound Management of Operational Risk.5 Regulatory expectations on cyber are no longer aspirational: they are built into how supervisors assess banks and carry reporting consequences.
Trends and Insights: Payments, Platforms, and AI Are Rewiring the Customer Interface
The customer-facing layer of financial services is being rebuilt. Institutions that understand this as a structural shift, rather than a technology upgrade, will be the ones best positioned to compete over the next decade.
Digital payments have crossed the threshold from trend to baseline expectation
Digital payments are now nearly universal. Roughly nine in ten consumers in both the US and Europe made a digital payment in the past year, and the US reached a new high of 92 percent in 2024.7 Digital wallets are becoming part of everyday shopping: one in five people who use them often leave home without a physical wallet.7 This is not a channel preference. It is a fundamental shift in how financial services are accessed and experienced.
Online shopping is still the most common use, with adoption holding around 70 percent of US consumers, while in-app and in-store payments are growing fastest.7 In the US, in-app digital payments have reached 60 percent adoption, up eight points since 2019.7
Instant payments are growing exponentially and fragmenting the payments value chain
Real-time payment systems now run in almost every major market.8 In Canada, the Real-Time Rail went live on November 9, 2026, letting banks, credit unions, and payment providers clear and settle payments in real time, 24 hours a day, every day of the year.9 In the European Union, the number of instant payment transactions is projected to grow from about three billion in 2024 to almost 30 billion by 2028, an average annual growth rate of 50 percent.8
Digital wallets are now the world’s leading way to pay, accounting for 33 percent of in-store spending globally in 2025.10 As transaction volume shifts toward lower-yield rails such as instant payments, monetization challenges are rising, particularly in markets with strict regulations on interchange and processing fees.
For incumbent institutions, this creates a dual challenge: investing in infrastructure that supports faster, lower-yield rails while protecting the economics of higher-yield products that still drive profitability. Few institutions have a settled answer to this tension yet.
Institutions are responding by bringing technology capability back in-house
Redesigning a customer journey end to end, from the offer to who answers the phone and how the customer is served afterwards, requires owning the data, the architecture, and the execution capability, not outsourcing them.
The direction is clear. Institutions are no longer competing only on products or balance sheets. They are competing on architecture, data, and execution speed. The advantage increasingly belongs to those that can translate customer insight into product and service change quickly, with appropriate governance and risk controls in place.
Opportunities and Solutions: Prioritize Core Modernization, Resilience, and Governed AI
The strongest response to the current environment is not to launch more transformation programs. It is to focus relentlessly on a smaller number of priorities and execute them with discipline.
The differentiator is not the strategy. It is the execution quality. For most financial services institutions, that means concentrating attention on four areas.
Modernize core and data architecture to support faster products and cleaner reporting
Legacy infrastructure is the most consistent constraint on execution speed in financial services. Institutions cannot build personalized customer propositions, respond quickly to competitive threats, or produce clean regulatory reporting when the underlying data architecture is fragmented or outdated. Core modernization is not a technology project. It is an operating model project. It requires decisions about what to build, what to buy, what to retire, and how to sequence change without disrupting the operations that customers and regulators depend on every day.
Embed cyber and operational resilience into every major change initiative
Resilience that is added to transformation programs as a compliance layer is both expensive and insufficient. It needs to be designed in from the beginning. The final Basel III standards set out a single standardized approach for calculating the capital banks hold against operational risk.11 Institutions that treat resilience as a strategic capability, rather than overhead, will have a structural advantage as regulatory expectations continue to climb.
Apply AI where there is clear business value and strong governance
The potential effect of AI on financial services is significant. The institutions that will benefit most are not the ones moving fastest. They are the ones moving most deliberately: identifying the highest-value use cases, establishing governance frameworks that can satisfy both internal risk standards and regulatory scrutiny, and building the data and organizational infrastructure that AI actually requires to perform reliably. Fraud detection, customer servicing, credit decisioning, and regulatory reporting are the areas where the business case is clearest and where governance requirements are most tractable today.
Redesign customer journeys to reduce friction without weakening trust or control
Customers now expect the experience of financial services to match the experience they have with the best digital platforms in other sectors. Closing that gap requires journey redesign that is as rigorous about risk and control as it is about customer experience, which is harder than the typical CX framing suggests.
Conclusion: Winning Institutions Will Simplify Before They Accelerate
Financial services are not becoming simpler. They are becoming more software-defined, more distributed across platforms and intermediaries, and more dependent on disciplined execution. Banks that outperform choose their segments carefully, find scale where it matters, and execute rigorously across analytics, marketing, operating model, and technology.3 Management and execution capability is becoming the differentiator, and the institutions that have not yet treated it as such are the ones most exposed.
The institutions best positioned to win over the next five years will be the ones that can simplify their operating models before attempting to accelerate them. That means making deliberate choices about which initiatives to pursue, designing governance structures that keep execution on track, embedding resilience into change rather than bolting it on, and building the internal capabilities that sustained advantage requires.
Complexity is not the enemy. Unmanaged complexity is. The institutions that learn to execute with clarity and discipline inside a complex environment will set the competitive standard for the decade ahead.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the financial services market trading at a discount despite record profits?
Profitability is real, but confidence is not. The sector posted record net income of $1.3 trillion in 2025, and yet banks carry a price-to-book ratio of 1, 67 percent below the average for other industries. What markets are pricing is the gap between the financial performance and the capability to sustain it through regulatory change, nonbank competition, and the cost of running technology that does not yet do what it should. The discount is on execution, not on earnings.
How is regulation different from what it used to be?
It has moved well beyond capital and liquidity into operational resilience, third-party technology oversight, and consumer data access. The Basel Committee revised its Core Principles for the first time since 2012, and the EU’s Digital Operational Resilience Act has applied since January 17, 2025, requiring firms to report major technology incidents and test their digital resilience regularly. The practical implication is that compliance can no longer be run as a separate workstream. Resilience has to be designed into transformation programs from the first day, because adding it later costs more and works less well.
Where are nonbank competitors actually winning, and why?
In the most profitable pools: private credit, payments, and wealth management. These competitors are not carrying legacy infrastructure or the full weight of prudential regulation, which lets them design more focused propositions and move faster than an incumbent typically can. The advantage that used to come from balance sheet size is now contingent on something more uncomfortable. Local scale still matters in many markets, but complexity inside a large institution will often negate the scale advantage that the size of the institution was meant to deliver.
What does it actually take to compete on instant payments without losing the economics?
Two things at once, which is what makes it difficult. Volume is moving onto lower-yield rails: account-to-account, digital wallets, and instant payments are growing fast, and EU instant payment volumes are projected to rise from roughly three billion in 2024 to nearly thirty billion by 2028. Institutions have to invest in the infrastructure that supports those rails while protecting the economics of higher-yield products that still produce most of the profit. Few have a settled answer yet, and the ones that do treat it as an operating model question, not a payments‑team question.
How should banks approach AI given the regulatory and risk environment?
Deliberately rather than quickly. The institutions extracting real value from AI are not the ones moving fastest. They are the ones identifying the use cases where the business case is clear and the governance is tractable (fraud detection, customer servicing, credit decisioning, and regulatory reporting) and building the data and organizational infrastructure that AI requires to perform reliably. The differentiator is rarely the model. It is whether the institution can deploy AI inside a framework that satisfies internal risk standards and regulatory scrutiny at the same time.
Where should a financial services leadership team start if the transformation portfolio is overloaded?
Simplify before accelerating. That means modernizing the core and data architecture so faster products and cleaner reporting become possible, embedding resilience into change rather than layering it on afterwards, applying AI only where the business case and the governance are both ready, and redesigning customer journeys with as much rigour on risk and control as on customer experience. Complexity is not the enemy. Unmanaged complexity is, and the institutions learning to execute with clarity inside a complex environment will set the standard for the decade ahead.
Sources
- McKinsey & Company. (2025). Global Banking Annual Review 2025: Why Precision, Not Heft, Defines the Future of Banking. New York, NY: McKinsey & Company.
- McKinsey & Company. (2026). Global Banking Annual Review 2026: The AI Disruption Dividend. New York, NY: McKinsey & Company.
- McKinsey & Company. (2024). Global Banking Annual Review 2024: Attaining Escape Velocity. New York, NY: McKinsey & Company.
- Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (2024). Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision. Basel, Switzerland: Bank for International Settlements.
- Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (2021). Principles for Operational Resilience. Basel, Switzerland: Bank for International Settlements.
- European Parliament and Council of the European Union. (2022). Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 on Digital Operational Resilience for the Financial Sector (DORA). Luxembourg: Official Journal of the European Union.
- McKinsey & Company. (2024). State of Consumer Digital Payments in 2024. New York, NY: McKinsey & Company.
- McKinsey & Company. (2024). Global Payments in 2024: Simpler Interfaces, Complex Reality. New York, NY: McKinsey & Company.
- Payments Canada. (2026). Canada Launches the Real-Time Rail, Bringing 24/7 Payment Infrastructure to the National Economy. Ottawa, ON: Payments Canada.
- Global Payments (Worldpay). (2026). Global Payments Report 2026: The Trends Redefining Payments. Atlanta, GA: Global Payments.
- Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). (2023). Basel Framework, OPE25: Standardised Approach to Operational Risk. Basel, Switzerland: Bank for International Settlements.